Brownstones Coffee Sayville, located at 229 W Main St, is a charming eatery that has quickly become a local favorite. Known for its inviting atmosphere reminiscent of a classic diner, it offers a delightful range of breakfast and brunch options that consistently impress visitors. Many customers rave about their experiences, highlighting the excellent service and diverse menu choices.
Alejandro Corpeño enjoyed a laid-back breakfast with friends, declaring it did not disappoint. Beth Santagata celebrated her mother's birthday at Brownstones, appreciating the no-wait access, delicious menu, and top-notch service. Jamila Afrika, who stumbled upon the gem while waiting for the Cross Sound Ferry, praised their corned beef hash and the creative specialty drink menu, including fun cereal and mimosa flights.
For lunch, Bryan Coon relished a perfectly crafted Cobb Salad, while his wife's crepes were a standout as well. Many have noted that the friendly staff, like Silvia, contribute to a comforting dining experience. With its blend of quality food, exceptional service, and a cozy atmosphere, Brownstones Coffee Sayville is well worth a visit, making it an ideal stop for both locals and visitors alike.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Highlights
Has fast service
Serves great coffee
Has great tea selection
Popular for
Popular for breakfast
Popular for lunch
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves alcohol
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Quick bite
Dining options
Serves breakfast
Serves brunch
Serves lunch
Has catering
Has counter service
Serves dessert
Has seating
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy
Crowd
Good for groups
Popular with tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs available
Has kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Photos
Reviews For Brownstones Coffee Sayville
alejandro corpeño
Jun 25,2025
Had breakfast with long time friends. Did not disappoint. I recommend
Beth Santagata
Jun 2,2025
We went to Brownstones in Sayville for brunch to celebrate my mom’s birthday, and it was a great experience! There was no wait, plenty of delicious options on the menu, and the service was excellent. We’ll definitely be back!
Jamila Afrika
May 15,2025
Loved having brunch here! We missed the Cross Sound Ferry back to Rhode Island and ended up staying the night in a nearby hotel. We were searching for a place near the Sayville ferry and this popped up. It was worth every moment. The place was PACKED on a Sunday morning, but we were able to get bar seating. I, the co-pilot got the corned beef hash. And it was DELICIOUS. Definitely properly cut and certainly not from a can! My Pilot got the eggs and avocado Benedict with turkey bacon and it too was delicious! Their specialty drink menu looked fun, if you're not driving try the cereal or mimosa flights! I can see how this is easily a local favorite. While our server was not as attentive as they could've been, I'd still go out of my way to eat before or after catching the Sayville ferry!
Bryan Coon
May 1,2025
Visited the Brownstones Coffee restaurant in downtown Sayville for lunch. The building used to be the Sayville Diner. It has been converted into the Brownstones Coffee restaurant without losing the charm of the original diner while including all of the decorations and feel of a true Brownstones Coffee restaurant. My Cobb Salad with chicken was one of the best Cobb Salads I've had. While my wife's crepes were cooked just right and flavorful. I highly recommend any of the Brownstones Coffee restaurant locations!
Kevin Shapiro
Apr 24,2025
Very good bfast fare. Service was super Silvia took great care of us!
Angela Barclay
Apr 22,2025
Came here for lunch. Got the Greek salad, it was a huge serving and so delicious. My daughter got the chocolate chip pancakes which were also yummy. There was an issue with my mom’s order but it was quickly resolved by the server. Food and service were great and a lovely atmosphere.
Marisa Crowley
Apr 8,2025
My boyfriend and I came here for a breakfast date since we wanted to try out a new place! The staff was very friendly, and they were very informative, and helpful when it came to ordering! The atmosphere was very modern, and had a nice aesthetic to it so it’s excellent for social media pictures, or for food blog posts! The tables were very clean, and the bathrooms were very clean and had a very cool design, it’s amazing how clean and different the place is as I used to go here previously when it was a diner! Anyhow, let’s get started on our meals so my boyfriend got the Fried Chicken Belgian Waffle with a side of loaded home fries and hollandaise sauce. He said he really enjoyed the meal, although he wished the waffles had more syrup to go with it and butter. However, the loaded home fries were beyond phenomenal! I highly recommend on getting this! I got the BEC sandwich, it’s bacon, egg, and cheese on a croissant with a side of home fries which was absolutely amazing! I’d definitely get this again, as the croissant was so soft and buttery that it just melts in your mouth. I highly recommend on getting this as well, and the size portions are really good! Overall, I recommend this place for a good breakfast or brunch whether it’s dining in or takeout! I’ve ordered takeout from this place on doordash, and it’s never failed to disappoint me! I also recommend on getting the Mozzarella Avocado Toast and the Bruschetta Avocado Toast as they are both absolutely fantastic!!!
Thomas McGiveron
Apr 1,2025
The vibe is great. The service was friendly. I ordered the BLT Avocado Eggs Benedict with arugula on a slice of ciabatta toast with breakfast potatoes. My significant other had the house omelet (she orders fries with her eggs - piping hot good). We also had the delicious salted caramel coffee. The food was excellent - hot and flavorful. The hollandaise sauce along with the avocado did cool my eggs a little but I enjoyed it. I've also been there and had just the eggs and bacon with toast - good solid dish. The prices are good for the location, cleanliness and decor of this newly updated establishment and most importantly the value-for-money is good.
Reviews For Brownstones Coffee Sayville